- a sore throat that feels like I'm swallowing razor blades
- that dry, hacking cough that keeps me (and Mrs. Bastard) up for nights on end
- nasal congestion that makes me feel like I'm trying to breathe through a pillow
- the general feeling of shittiness like I want to crawl directly into a coffin and close the lid
Ahem. Sorry about that. Where was I? Right, my cold. At work I do my damndest to keep myself presentable and not snozzle on my patients. Yes, "snozzle" is the technical term. Unfortunately I suppose I wasn't doing a good enough job of faking it, which prompted my patient to turn the tables and give me some helpful (yet unsolicited) medical advice:
"Doc, you should go get some Oscillo! It works great whenever I have a cold."
She must have seen the blank look on my face (though I may have just been daydreaming of my impending death), so she said, "You know, oscillococcinum. It's wonderful!"
Oscillo? The name sounded familiar, but I couldn't place it. Was it a brand name of a new cold medicine? Had I seen an advert somewhere for it? Had I taken it as a child perhaps? I thanked her for the recommendation, and on my way home I stopped at my local apothecary/pharmacy/drug store/chemist to have a look and find my salvation.
I walked down the "Cold and Flu" aisle and saw the usual suspects, the medicines with the long, unpronounceable names which had become my best friends since my plague began - phenylephrine, guaifenesin, pseudoephedrine, dextromethorphan, doxylamine. And then . . . I spotted it.
GOD. DAMN. IT.
I think I actually said "FUCK!" out loud when I spotted it, much to the chagrin of the elderly lady behind me looking at the selection of laxatives. For those of you unfamiliar with the concept, homeopathy is based partly on the outdated and wholly-unscientific concept of "similia similibus curantur", or that like cures like (in case you forgot your Latin). In other words, if you have an ailment, it can be treated by giving a small dose of the causative agent. Hippocrates (yes, he of the oath) is said to have started the practice by treating mania with small doses of mandrake root, which can also cause symptoms of mania when give in larger doses. Samuel Hahnemann expanded the idea in the 1800's when he ate some cinchona bark (which was used to treat malaria) and developed symptoms similar to those of malaria which the cinchona was supposed to treat.
In a brilliant feat of psuedoscientific flatulence, Hahnemann postulated that if small doses are good, then smaller doses should be better. He began diluting things like salt, arsenic, and bushmaster snake venom by factors of 100 (which he oxymoronically called "potentisation") and then striking the solution against an elastic object in a process he called "succussion" (his object of choice was a wooden board covered by leather and stuffed with horse hair - yes, seriously). He would then dilute it by a factor of 100 again. And then again by 100. And again. And again. And . . . you get the point. Followers of homeopathy believe that despite the dilution, the water somehow "remembers" the property of whatever is being diluted . . . which of course is physically impossible and firmly enters the realm of magic.
As I remembered this information, I looked at the box to see what the ingredients were, and what I saw actually made me laugh. I may even have uttered the word "LOL" aloud by accident (the lady behind me was still choosing her laxative). Directly from the box:
Active Ingredient: Anas Barbariae Hepatis Et Cordis Extractum 200CK HPUSTo Reduce the Duration & Severity of Flu-Like SymptomsWhat the hell does that mean? Well if you had paid more attention in Latin class (haven't we been through this already?) you'd remember that "Anas barbariae" is a type of duck, and that "hepatis et cordis" means "liver and heart". To prepare this concoction, they first take...
"Wait wait wait. Duck liver and heart? What the fuck are you on about, Doc? I thought this was supposed to be a flu remedy?"
Ok, let me explain. No, there is too much. Let me sum up. You see, Joseph Roy, a French physician practicing during the 1918 influenza pandemic (which killed about 5% of the world's population) looked at the blood of flu victims under a microscope and saw some oscillating bacteria which he called "oscillococcus". He postulated (incorrectly) that this was causing the flu (as well as rheumatism, measles, cancer, and tuberculosis). He then continued his search for a cure until he found the mysterious oscillococcus again, this time in duck liver. Operating under the premise of "similia similibus curantur" he prepared a remedy by serially diluting bits of duck liver and heart. Now other than Dr. Roy, no one in the history of mankind has ever seen this oscillococcus, so I don't know what the hell he thought he was seeing. Regardless, we now know that the cold (and flu) are caused by a virus, not bacteria. As ridiculous as it is, it at least lends a whole new meaning to the term "quack", though. Har har.
Anyway, I looked back at the description of Oscillococcinum. See that "200CK"? That means it's been diluted by a factor of 100 not once, not twice, but 200 times. It is so dilute that you would need to take 2 billion oscillo tablets to even get ONE MOLECULE of the "active ingredient", which doesn't even have any medicinal property anyway! Then I took a look at the ingredients on the back of the box:
But wait, it gets more absurd - go back and look at the "drug" facts. It warns against giving a pure sugar pill to pregnant or breastfeeding women. It also recommends consulting with a doctor before giving a sugar pill to children under 2. Since when do we not give sugar to pregnant women or children? My daughter would be heartbroken if she could never again eat M&Ms (which have exactly as much medicinal properties as oscillococcinium, by the way).
And it gets even worse. The box says it "Works Naturally with Your Body", is "Non-Drowsy", has "No Side Effect:", and has "No Drug Interactions". OF COURSE it won't interact with anything, put you to sleep, or have any effect whatsoever. It is, quite literally, a sugar pill and nothing else.
I put the box back on the shelf with no intention of wasting my money and went home. When I got there I started digging a bit deeper, and I realised it gets even worse. These tablets are available for sale on Amazon for the low price of $15.21 for 12 tablets in the US, CDN$33.94 for 30 in Canada., or ￥1,731 for 30 in Japan. Sadly, they are not available (on Amazon, at least) in UK, France, Australia, Germany, China, Austria, or Spain. Yes you read that correctly - they are actually MORE expensive than actual cold medicines which actually DO have actual active ingredients (ie medicine) in them.
The absolute worst part is the comments people have written about the product:
- anything homeopathic is good
- excellent flu remedy
- NO medicinal negative side effects (because it's homeopathic)
- It sounds to good to be true, but this method as been used and refined for 2000 years in countries far older than our U.S.A.
- Placebo Power? Maybe, but it seems to work for me.
- Homeopathic meds remember memory of water basically.
- Oscillococcinum is a life saver!
Now if you'll excuse me, I have a coffin to crawl into.
You know latin?ReplyDelete
Interesting post. I loved the history part. It completed the picture.
Get well soon doctor. It is a pitty you can't take a break. Rest will help you.
I have found the best meds to lighten flu symptoms are these: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theraflu (in my corner of europe they are called neocitran) or (the one time i was in canada) a combo of dayquill and nyquill. And I promise, they are not homeopathic.ReplyDelete
Also, this video about homeopathic ER might amuse you: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=bgxzSUxxRzE
Get well soon, Doc!
...passes Doc the M&Ms. .. (personally, I found the light brown ones the most effective, blue is completely useless as a remedy for anything but PMS. We all know about red and green.)ReplyDelete
Well, doc, google "medorrhinum". It's way more creative than some ordinary heart and liver :P . Quack quack.ReplyDelete
I was told by my physician to try this. I did and it did nothing for me. A few years before that one of my PCP's colleagues was a proponent of magnets for all manner of aches and pains. Another dear friend who has been an RN for 30 years is a firm believer in homeopathy and has spend thousands and thousands of dollars on advanced homeopathy "education" and carries her Arnica everywhere. And she's one of the most "anti-science" people I know.ReplyDelete
I thought it was only in the greater SF Bay Area that all these holisticy people existed!
Mucinex=miracle drug when I get the annual spring crud, 2014's version has NOT yet happened—is this the year I buck the trend? Here's hoping you whip that nasty virus soon and that you don't progress to a superimposed bacterial infection (like I always do... damned asthmatic lungs!).ReplyDelete
A doc suffering from a cold like us mere mortals makes my day a smidge better. Okay, not really, I'd rather have a sinus infection than a cold. At least a sinus infection has a nearly clear course it's going to run. That said, rest, hydrate, nutrition, and treating symptoms seem to be the best way to wait out those pesky adenovirus rascals.ReplyDelete
I can't wait until the next time my all natural friends use their homeopathic remedies! I'll tell them it's duck liver.
Hope you're feeling better doc and thanks for the laughs!
First of all, I'm sorry you're not feeling well. I hope you're on the mend. And I agree cold's are the worst.ReplyDelete
I'm afraid to admit I'm one that will take people's recommendation without properly researching it. Thank you for the education.
I'm afraid though to look into my favorite cough syrup that I get in Ireland while traveling. I swear by it. Maybe it's all in my head, but I want it to be my miracle drug.
And you even tossed in a Princess Bride reference! You are even cooler in my book!ReplyDelete
Hey Doc, I'm a little confused here. You said that "like cures like" is b.s....but isn't that what vaccines essentially do? I understand having 1 molecule in 20 tables of sugar isn't going to do anything, but the general idea seems sound to me. What am I missing here?ReplyDelete
They are not remotely the same. The basic tenet behind homeopathy is that whatever substance causes the same symptoms as a disease will cure it, but only if it is diluted beyond all reason and logic. With vaccines, you are introducing antigens (either pieces of a virus or bacteria or a killed/attenuated version of it) into the body which stimulates the immune system to create antibodies against them. Vaccines aren't a cure for anything; they are purely preventative.Delete
I hope that makes sense.
It does! Thank you:)Delete
I went to the pharmacy today to pick up a prescription, and while I was waiting I went looking for this pill out of curiosity because it just seems too ludicrous to be real. But alas, I found it amidst the Airborne and other preventative pills. When I picked it up and read the box I actually laughed out loud (and got several funny looks from the lady next to me). I guess putting the 'active ingredient' in Latin makes it legit.ReplyDelete